Is Brake Cleaner the Same as Carb Cleaner? Key Differences Every Mechanic Should Know
Wondering what the differences are between carb cleaner vs. brake cleaner? Our experts break down when to use each and how to avoid costly mistakes.
Whether you need a low VOC brake cleaner depends on where you buy and use it. California, Canada, and the stricter OTC Phase IV states, including Ohio and Michigan, cap brake cleaner at 10% VOC by weight. Illinois and Indiana allow up to 45%, and states without their own consumer products rule follow only the federal standard, which doesn’t set a brake cleaner limit.
For shops, fleets, and purchasing teams, that patchwork matters. A brake cleaner that's legal on a shelf in Chicago may not be legal to sell in Columbus. Here's what VOC means in brake cleaner, which states regulate it, how the rules break down across the Midwest, and how to pick a compliant product that still cleans the way you need it to.
VOC in brake cleaner is the solvent content that evaporates quickly, carrying grease, brake fluid, and dust off the part. That fast evaporation is why brake cleaner works, and it's also why states regulate it.
| Definition: Volatile organic compound (VOC). A carbon-based chemical that evaporates easily and reacts with sunlight to form ground-level ozone (smog). On a brake cleaner label, VOC content is shown as a percentage of the product's weight. |
Low VOC brake cleaners contain 10% or less regulated VOC, while conventional formulas can run 45% or higher. The key word is "regulated." The EPA's VOC definition exempts compounds with negligible smog-forming reactivity, and acetone has been on that list since 1995. That's how many low VOC products stay under 10% and still clean effectively.
States regulate brake cleaner VOC levels through consumer products rules, and most of them follow either California's standard or one of the Ozone Transport Commission (OTC) model rules. The federal consumer products rule, in effect since 1998, doesn't include a brake cleaner category, so states without their own rule have no brake cleaner VOC limit.
Brake Cleaner VOC Limits by Region |
||
|---|---|---|
|
Region or tier |
Brake cleaner VOC limit (by weight) |
Who's covered |
|
California (CARB) |
10% |
Statewide since Dec. 31, 2010 |
|
Canada |
10% |
Nationwide |
|
New Jersey |
10% |
Statewide |
|
OTC Phase IV states |
10% |
CO, CT, DE, MD, MI, NH, NY, OH, RI, and parts of UT |
|
OTC Phase II states |
45% |
DC, IL, IN, MA, ME, PA, and parts of VA |
|
Federal only |
No brake cleaner limit |
States without their own consumer products rule |
California has tightened its brake cleaner limit steadily, from 50% in 1997 to 45% in 2002, 20% in 2008, and 10% at the end of 2010, according to California's consumer products standards. Other states have followed on a lag, and more states have moved from Phase II to Phase IV limits in recent years.
The Midwest is split. Ohio and Michigan now require brake cleaner to contain 10% VOC or less. Illinois and Indiana allow up to 45%, and Wisconsin has no state brake cleaner VOC limit.
Midwest Brake Cleaner VOC Rules |
||
|---|---|---|
|
State |
VOC limit |
Details |
|
Ohio |
10% |
Statewide, effective July 1, 2023 (Ohio Admin. Code 3745-112-03) |
|
Michigan |
10% |
Adopted the 2012 OTC model rule for products after Dec. 31, 2022 (Mich. Admin. Code R. 336.1660) |
|
Illinois |
45% |
Statewide, effective July 1, 2009 (35 Ill. Adm. Code 223.205) |
|
Indiana |
45% |
Follows the OTC Phase II model rule |
|
Wisconsin |
No state limit |
No state consumer products VOC rule; federal rule has no brake cleaner category |
These rules apply where the product is sold or supplied, not just where it's sprayed.
That catches a lot of multi-state operations off guard. A fleet based in northern Indiana with terminals in Toledo and Detroit can legally stock a 45% product at home, but its Ohio and Michigan locations need a 10% product.
| Our Take: If you run locations in more than one state, standardize on a 10% brake cleaner. It's simpler than tracking which cans went to which shop, and it keeps you covered if your state tightens its rule next. |
Yes, for most brake jobs, a quality low VOC brake cleaner removes brake fluid, grease, and dust as well as a high VOC formula. The difference is in how it behaves, not whether it cleans.
Here's how high VOC vs. low VOC brake cleaner typically compares:
High VOC vs. Low VOC Brake Cleaner |
||
|---|---|---|
|
Factor |
High VOC (up to 45%+) |
Low VOC (10% or less) |
|
Cleaning power |
Strong |
Comparable for most brake work |
|
Evaporation |
Fast |
Often faster with acetone-heavy blends |
|
Where it's legal |
Phase II and federal-only states |
All 50 states and Canada |
|
Watch-outs |
Not sellable in 10% states |
Check compatibility with painted or plastic parts |
Low VOC formulas that rely on acetone can flash off faster and may be tougher on some plastics and painted surfaces, so test on an inconspicuous spot when you're cleaning near those materials. Both types are flammable, so ventilation and keeping ignition sources away still apply.
Chlorinated or non-chlorinated? That's a separate choice, and we break it down in our guide to the difference between chlorinated and non-chlorinated brake cleaner.
You can tell if a brake cleaner is VOC compliant by checking the label and the Safety Data Sheet for its VOC content, then comparing it to your state's limit. Don't rely on a generic "VOC compliant" claim alone, since a product compliant in Illinois at 45% isn't compliant in Ohio.
Use this quick check:
Could your current stock be out of compliance? If you're in Ohio or Michigan and haven't reviewed your brake cleaner since those rules changed, it's worth a look.
Not sure which brake cleaner meets your state's limit? Talk with our team →
For high-volume shops and fleets, the TRUEGARD Non-Chlorinated Brake Cleaner 55-gallon drum is the most cost-effective option. It's a professional-strength, non-chlorinated cleaner and degreaser that dries quickly without leaving residue, and it's safer around rubber seals and plastic parts than chlorinated formulas.
Need aerosols for the bay? Browse the full Brake Cleaner collection. Wondering how TRUEGARD stacks up against the big names? See our comparison of TRUEGARD brake cleaner and CRC. And if techs in your shop grab whatever can is closest, our post on whether brake cleaner is the same as carb cleaner explains why that's a bad habit.
VOC stands for volatile organic compounds, the solvents in brake cleaner that evaporate quickly and contribute to smog. A VOC percentage on the label shows how much of the product's weight is regulated VOC. Low VOC brake cleaners contain 10% or less, while conventional formulas can contain 45% or more.
No. Brake cleaner VOC limits are set by states, not the federal government. California, New Jersey, and OTC Phase IV states such as Ohio and Michigan require 10% or less. Illinois, Indiana, and other OTC Phase II states allow 45%, and states without a consumer products rule have no brake cleaner limit.
Ohio limits brake cleaner to 10% VOC by weight, effective July 1, 2023, under Ohio Administrative Code 3745-112-03. The rule applies statewide to products sold, supplied, or manufactured for sale in Ohio. Keller-Heartt can help Ohio shops and fleets confirm which brake cleaners meet that limit.
For most brake work, yes. Low VOC brake cleaners often use exempt solvents like acetone to remove brake fluid, grease, and dust effectively while staying under 10% regulated VOC. They can evaporate faster and may affect some plastics or paint, so test near sensitive surfaces first.
Check the label for a specific VOC percentage or a "50-state compliant" statement, then confirm the VOC content in Section 9 of the Safety Data Sheet. Compare that number to your state's limit. Keller-Heartt's team can confirm compliance for every state where you operate.
The rules generally regulate the sale and supply of brake cleaner within a state, so a product bought legally in Illinois may not be legal for a supplier to sell in Ohio. Multi-state operations should check each location's rules or standardize on a 10% product to stay covered everywhere. Keller-Heartt can help you find the right fit.
Wondering what the differences are between carb cleaner vs. brake cleaner? Our experts break down when to use each and how to avoid costly mistakes.
Know the difference between chlorinated and non-chlorinated brake cleaners and which is the safer option for your vehicles.
Truegard® brake cleaner offers dramatic cost savings over CRC for businesses that can buy brake cleaner in bulk 55-gallon drums.
Subscribe to the Keller-Heartt blog so you can sharpen your industry knowledge, gather helpful tips, and stay informed about changes or updates in the oil provider landscape.